Hello all! New here, and just perusing a few threads... Thought I'd chime in on this particular discussion- hope you don't mind!
Been a Judge owner for awhile now, using it for my night stand SD gun, as my 'carry while fishing' for snakes and javelinas, and also as my carry while flying the bush in Alaska. So I always carry a selection of various ammo in a pocket of my fishing vest.
I have put approx 1000 rds of .45 Colt (real loads, not Cowboy loads) through it, and another 30-40 rds of PDX1, SZX, Federal HD,and rifled slugs as well.
Shooting it in the 2.5" cyl x 4" barrel, it does everything I ask of it, and more! My 10 and 15 yd groups are all within 4-5", while 7 yd is within 3". This is shooting both 255gr fmj and 250gr hard cast, 7gr of HP-38. So I'm not sure what caused the inaccuracy one poster was relating. I find it pretty much hits what I point it at...
I'm looking forward to putting a few rounds of CCI through it, to see if it has the density to take out some of the rattlers I see on the ranches I go to here in Sth Texas (bagged one which was just under 14' long).
For my varied needs, I find the Judge really meets them, and in a really solid way.